POLITICS: The People vs. Parliament

The Verse’s Political Editor Marcel Adams discusses who is sovereign over the Brexit process. Is it the people who voted for it, or our elected representatives?

The recent parliamentary votes on the proposed amendments to the EU Withdrawal Bill have raised a significant question, which has been highlighted in a report ‘Brexit and our unprotected constitution’, of who is sovereign in regards to the debate over Brexit. Is it the people who voted for it, or the parliamentarians who we elect?

The process in which the vote took place suggests that the people are in fact sovereign. This is because it was a referendum that asked the whole electorate whether they wanted to ‘Remain’ or ‘Leave’. With the latter option prevailing by a margin of 52%-48%. However in reality, this argument is not as clear cut.

Now that the Brexit process is more firmly in the hands of parliament. It is now the case that parliament is flexing its muscles and becoming sovereign over how we leave. This was seen with a real threat to the government over the ‘Meaningful Vote’ amendment — which later saw government compromise to advert a defeat in the chamber. However, the fact that parliamentarians were able to put pressure suggests that they are in fact sovereign of the Brexit process.

Ironically, many of those who firmly opposed any of the amendments that returned to the Commons this week, were staunch Brexiters, such as Jacob Rees-Mogg or Boris Johnson, who during the campaign back in 2016, argued that Brexit would allow for parliament to be sovereign over our decisions. Now that parliament has regathered that mantra, they suddenly oppose it, which is ironic but also hypocritical.

The real concern in relation to who is sovereign is that in our political history, we have never been in a scenario like this that tests our constitution. In past uses of direct democracy in the UK, the people have always endorsed the side of the ‘establishment’. The Brexit vote however, saw people choose what a majority of parliamentarians opposed and shows where constitutional difficulties lie.

We can’t say who is truly sovereign over Brexit. As this is an unprecedented event and the sovereignty is entirely conflicted. The people were arguably sovereign over the decision, but parliament are now gaining the sovereignty over the process.

If Parliament is to thwart Brexit or even water it down to a point where it becomes unrecognisable. Then it truly puts the people against parliament, something that is damaging  for our constitution and for wider democracy.

The Verse Staff

Next Post

REVIEW: University of Brighton, Graduate Fashion Week ‘18 @ The Old Truman Brewery, 05/06/2018

Thu Jun 14 , 2018
The Verse’s Chloe Lawrence attends The University of Brighton’s graduate student fashion show at Graduate Fashion Week on 5th June 2018. Heading away from the sunny confines of our ‘oh so familiar’ Brighton, our own graduate fashion students showcased their final year collections at Graduate Fashion Week. GFW is a […]

Editorial Team

Editor In Chief

Charley Gale
contactverse@gmail.com

News Editor

Benjamin George
versenews@gmail.com

Entertainment Editor

Caitlin Quigley
verseentertain@gmail.com

Arts Editor

Ramsha Khan
versethearts@gmail.com

Sports Editor

Gerald O’Brien
versesports@gmail.com

Student Voice Editor

Liberty Gatcombe
verstudentvoice@gmail.com

Creative Editor

Alice Pierre
versecreate@gmail.com

Social Media Managers

Meg Compton & Lottie Bulmer
versecommunicate@gmail.com

 

About us

The Verse is run by students, for students. If you’re studying at University of Brighton and you’d like to get involved by writing for us or becoming a sub-editor, we welcome you to contact us via email.

The Verse is funded and supported by Brighton Students’ Union.

The views expressed on The Verse online newspaper do not necessarily represent the views of Brighton Students’ Union, its management or employees. For more information or for any enquiries, please contact the Marketing and Communications Team at bsucommunications@brighton.ac.uk